So I saved an essay as draft, then I published it as live (same screen). But it didn't seem to work (refreshed but still not seeing it). Set as Featured (hoping it'll make it to the main Essay page - I'm using Boulevard theme) and still nothing.
Then I don't know what I did, but I eventually saw the "Publish live" on the button again (as oppsoed to save changes).
It might be possbile that if you click it once, it publishes and if you click again, it doesn't (goes back to draft).
This question has received the maximum number of answers.